Etsy has become the ultimate online marketplace for everything handmade, vintage, and wonderfully unique—and when it comes to jewelry, the platform shines brighter than ever. Whether you’re searching for a dainty everyday necklace, an engagement ring with a twist, or bold statement earrings that no one else will have, Etsy is a treasure trove. But with thousands of shops to scroll through, where do you even begin?
To help you out, we’ve rounded up some of the top jewelry stores on Etsy—ones that have earned glowing reviews, loyal fanbases, and reputations for quality, style, and craftsmanship. From minimalist gold pieces to celestial designs and vintage gems, these are the standout shops worth adding to your favorites list.
1. GLDNxLayeredAndLong
If you’re a fan of minimalist, personalized jewelry with a meaningful twist, GLDNxLayeredAndLong is your go-to. This shop is one of the most popular on Etsy—and for good reason. Their dainty gold and silver pieces are fully customizable with initials, names, coordinates, or dates, making them perfect gifts (for others or yourself).
Best For:
- Personalized necklaces and bracelets
- Everyday layering pieces
- Gifts with sentimental value
Shop Highlight: The custom name necklace is a bestseller—elegant, simple, and timeless.
2. MinimalVS
Clean lines, geometric shapes, and affordable luxury define MinimalVS. This shop caters to those who love the minimalist aesthetic but still want their jewelry to feel intentional and high-end. Most items are crafted from 14k gold-filled or sterling silver, which means they’re durable and hypoallergenic.
Best For:
- Sleek, modern designs
- Stacking rings and bangles
- Subtle yet striking pieces
Shop Highlight: The hammered gold stacking ring set is delicate yet eye-catching.
3. LeChaim
LeChaim specializes in bohemian-inspired, nature-themed jewelry with a modern flair. Think celestial motifs, natural stones, and organic shapes. Each piece feels like a tiny work of art, perfect for those who lean into earthy, ethereal vibes.
Best For:
- Gemstone rings and earrings
- Moon and star-inspired designs
- Boho-chic aesthetic
Shop Highlight: The opal moonstone ring is a fan favorite for its dreamy glow.
4. MuseNest
MuseNest blends vintage glam with modern elegance. The pieces are delicate, often incorporating pearls, crystals, and fine metalwork. Many brides turn to MuseNest for their wedding-day jewelry, but the shop also offers everyday options that are just as romantic.
Best For:
- Bridal jewelry
- Vintage-style accessories
- Elegant earrings and hairpieces
Shop Highlight: Their bridal drop earrings have earned rave reviews for beauty and comfort.
5. LayeredAndLoved
LayeredAndLoved lives up to its name by offering jewelry that’s made for layering. This U.S.-based shop crafts high-quality pieces in gold-filled, rose gold, and sterling silver. Their simple yet chic designs make mixing and matching easy and fun.
Best For:
- Layered necklace sets
- Initial and birthstone jewelry
- Customizable charm bracelets
Shop Highlight: Their zodiac constellation necklaces are subtle and stylish.
6. GracePersonalized
As the name suggests, GracePersonalized specializes in customized jewelry—everything from engraved rings to coordinate bar necklaces. Each item is made to order, and the attention to detail is impressive. Plus, the packaging is beautiful, which makes gift-giving even easier.
Best For:
- Personalized rings and bangles
- Anniversary and birthday gifts
- Jewelry with names, dates, or messages
Shop Highlight: The custom handwriting bracelet is incredibly meaningful and unique.
7. WanderAndLustJewelry
This female-founded shop focuses on creating affordable luxury using high-quality materials. Think 14k gold-filled and AAA-grade gemstones. Their pieces are elegant yet wearable, with a dash of wanderlust energy.
Best For:
- Delicate gemstone necklaces
- Nature-inspired charms
- Everyday fine jewelry
Shop Highlight: The rose quartz pendant necklace is a fan favorite for its soft pink hue and healing vibes.
8. YugenTribe
If you’re into space, science, or mythology, YugenTribe will absolutely capture your imagination. Their pieces often incorporate cosmic elements like stars, galaxies, planets, and even NASA images. The designs are unique, meaningful, and often educational.
Best For:
- Space lovers and stargazers
- Statement pieces with a story
- Gifts for the science-inclined
Shop Highlight: The Galaxy spinner necklace features real images from NASA—how cool is that?
9. TinySilver
Based in Thailand, TinySilver offers—you guessed it—tiny silver jewelry. But don’t let the word “tiny” fool you: these pieces are full of personality. Their whimsical, playful designs include animals, nature motifs, and geometric forms. Everything is handcrafted with love.
Best For:
- Sterling silver studs and charms
- Playful and unique designs
- Affordable gifting
Shop Highlight: Their animal earrings (like tiny foxes or elephants) are irresistibly cute.
10. CaitlynMinimalist
With nearly 2 million sales, CaitlynMinimalist is one of the top-selling jewelry shops on Etsy. The pieces are sleek, elegant, and almost always customizable. From nameplate necklaces to dainty birthstone rings, the shop covers all bases for everyday staples and meaningful gifts.
Best For:
- Custom name and initial jewelry
- Modern minimalist lovers
- Fast shipping and consistent quality
Shop Highlight: The signature name necklace is perfect for personal flair.
11. BYCHARI
BYCHARI brings a high-fashion edge to Etsy. The shop’s sleek gold jewelry has been featured in major magazines and even worn by celebrities—including Michelle Obama. The designs are simple yet powerful, designed to be worn daily and layered endlessly.
Best For:
- Trend-forward, celeb-approved jewelry
- High-quality gold pieces
- Investment jewelry that lasts
Shop Highlight: Their “Vote” necklace made waves in 2020 and remains a powerful statement.
12. AuTerra
Sustainable shoppers, take note. AuTerra creates eco-friendly jewelry using recycled silver and gold, as well as ethically sourced stones. The designs are earthy and modern, with a strong emphasis on environmental responsibility.
Best For:
- Eco-conscious consumers
- Recycled metal jewelry
- Unique, handmade statement pieces
Shop Highlight: The recycled silver hoop earrings are stylish and sustainable.
13. MadeByMary
MadeByMary combines handcrafted artistry with modern design. Their jewelry is all about storytelling—each piece is made to represent something personal, whether it’s a birth month flower, a meaningful date, or a mantra. Everything is designed, stamped, and assembled in-house.
Best For:
- Personalized keepsake pieces
- Gifts for moms, sisters, and besties
- Meaningful mementos
Shop Highlight: The disc pendant necklaces let you choose your own word or date—simple, yet powerful.
14. FerkosFineJewelry
Looking for fine jewelry without the luxury price tag? FerkosFineJewelry offers solid gold and diamond pieces that are elegant and timeless. Their engagement rings, in particular, are wildly popular thanks to their understated beauty and excellent craftsmanship.
Best For:
- Engagement rings and bridal jewelry
- Diamond studs and bands
- Solid gold lovers
Shop Highlight: The oval diamond solitaire ring is both trendy and timeless.
15. HoopsByHand
As the name suggests, HoopsByHand specializes in—you guessed it—hoop earrings. But this isn’t just any hoop shop. Each pair is handcrafted in the U.S. and comes in a variety of metals, styles, and sizes. Whether you want tiny huggies or big bold hoops, they’ve got you covered.
Best For:
- Hoop earrings of all styles
- Handmade wire jewelry
- Affordable fine metals
Shop Highlight: The infinity-style hoops are simple, secure, and endlessly stylish.
Final Thoughts
Etsy is more than just a shopping platform—it’s a community of talented artisans pouring passion and creativity into their work. These top jewelry stores represent the best of what Etsy has to offer, combining style, substance, and that extra-special handmade touch you won’t find at big-box retailers.
Whether you’re shopping for a gift, an engagement ring, or just something sparkly for yourself, these shops are a great place to start. Happy treasure hunting!
FAQ
1. Is it safe to buy jewelry on Etsy?
Yes, Etsy is a reputable platform with a secure checkout process and buyer protection policies. Always read reviews, check shop ratings, and review return policies before purchasing. Many top shops (like the ones listed above) have thousands of 5-star reviews, which is a great indicator of trust and quality.
2. How do I know if the jewelry is good quality?
Check for the materials used—look for terms like “14k gold-filled,” “sterling silver,” or “solid gold.” These are typically higher quality and longer-lasting than plated or costume jewelry. Customer reviews and close-up product photos can also give you insight into craftsmanship and durability.
3. Can I request custom or personalized pieces from Etsy sellers?
Absolutely! In fact, many Etsy jewelry shops specialize in personalization. You can often customize names, initials, birthstones, dates, or even upload your own handwriting or coordinates. Most shops are happy to work with you—just message the seller if you have a unique idea or special request.